"How's the head?"

Atticus obviously doesn't appear at Rufus' side like some demonic nightmare phantom, but he sure does take some pleasure in showing up with little warning where he isn't wanted. By the looks of him, he hasn't imbibed any of the vials yet; the rules of Penance apparently apply to other people.

(Doubtless, he'll face the consequences of these choices later. He almost anticipates them.)